The ‘GORDON SHIELD’ as it is known was presented to Scouting towards the end of 1914 by the Gordon’s Institute as “An Annual Competition against Cape Peninsula Scouts”. Since then (the first competition being in 1915) it has been held every year without fail, through two World Wars and today it is still the most popular Cape Western Competition on the Scouting calendar.
History of the Gordon Shield
The Gordon Shield as existing today, was donated to the Boy Scouts Association in 1914 by Mr.W.G. Haines of the Gordons Institute as “An Annual Competition against Cape Peninsula Scouts.” Since then it has been held every year (except 1936), through two World Wars, and today is still the most popular Western Cape Competition on the Scouting calendar.
It was first competed for on Saturday 19th September 1915 at the Rifle Range in Clee Road, Observatory. The Competition was for First Aid and open to teams of five each. 2nd Cape Town (Y.M.C.A.) were the first ever winners. The following year the Competition was held covering signaling and shooting.
In 1917, the Competition became a Patrol Camp, run on very similar lines of Gordon Shield Competitions as it is today, and there have been no fundamental changes to the actual competition to this day.
One main change, however, came in the early 1920’s. A team who were absolute champions in signaling and signaling methods, lost all the 40 points for that test because of a misunderstanding, yet they still came second in the whole Competition by two points. It was then decided to give every test the same value – 5 points instead of one carrying 5 points and another 40. Thus there remained a fighting chance to win all through the various tests.
The tests, mainly on a Camp craft basis, covered the whole of the work for Tenderfoot, Trekker, Second Class, First Class and any proficiency badges held for the Competition. The unit of competition was a ‘Standing Patrol’, and except for certain exceptions the allocation of tests and duties were in the hands of the Patrol Leader. We are quite sure that the Gordon Shield is and was always a test of the Patrol System.
Teams have always been eight boys (in more recent years girls) from each Troop. At times, the Troop picked the best 8, even if they were all Patrol Leaders, but their ranks assumed for the Gordon Shield were one PL, one Second, and numbers 3, 4, 5, 6, 7 and 8. All members of the team then wore the same Patrol Colours, and the leader carried the Patrol Flag for those Colours.
The sites of the competitions varied, and some were even real strenuous hikes. In one competition, competitors met judges at the Grand Parade, Botanical Gardens, Kloof Nek, Woodhead Reservoir, Maclear’s Beacon, Constantia Nek and Hout Bay. Standing camps have also been held at: The Glen (Camps Bay), The Homestead (Oranjezicht), Gilcape (Diep River), The New Gilcape (Eerste River), Pinelands, Parow and Ramsay Park (now in the middle of the Cape Town International Airport).
From time to time, particular Troops have won the competition for several years in succession, and then in many instances have gone down and never staged a come-back. Others have usually been among the first ten at most times. The competition has always proved a ‘base of measurement’ for Troops and Patrols against the implementation of their working Patrol System, with skill and Scout knowledge also playing a major role.
History of the Centre Plaque
By J. Lumsden
ONE Sunday in 1909 six boys in Mr. W. Baker’s Second Claremont Troop of Scouts took part in two separate incidents which were destined to make Scouting history.
Three of these Scouts rescued a man from drowning at Fish Hoek on the Sunday afternoon, and for this meritorious deed, they were each awarded the Medal of Merit., the first award of its kind in the country since the Scout Movement started in 1908.
But it is the story of the other three boys that remains fresh, because they were photographed while hiking home after a weekend spent at Kommetje, and the scene inspired a firm of London metalworkers to make a plaque of this picture.
To-day, similar plaques on competition Scout shields are scattered all over the world – but interest locally centres on the fact that this picture is on the Gordon Shield, and awarded each year to the winners of the local Blue Ribbon of Scouting. This year’s competition, by the way, is taking place to-day and to-morrow.
Another interesting association with this picture is that it was taken by Arthur Elliott, whose collection of historic negatives were kept for the nation and now form part of the Archives.
Scoutmaster “Bill” Baker was a special friend of Arthur Elliott, and both were interested in photography. Arthur Elliott had a way with children, and several of his famous camera studies involved children. It was natural, therefore, that in a time when the Scout Movement was still young, he should see in three boys an ideal subject for his art.
On the Saturday Mr Baker’s son, Joe, with two of his fellow Scouts, Bill Seaton and John Jordan, set out for a week-end hike and camp at Kommetje.
Returning home along the Kommetje road, half-way to Fish Hoek, these boys were hailed by a man carrying a camera, case and tripod. Joe Baker recognized the man as Arthur Elliott, and after taking an individual photograph of each boy, he then took one of the group. These pictures of Scouts on a hike were in all ways authentic, as they had but paused a moment from their active Scouting to oblige a photographer.
They were wearing blue jerseys and shorts with the Scout hat, and they carried a staff. On Joe’s pole was flying his flag of rank as a patrol leader.
The pose was a favourite one of Baden-Powell’s and Joe Baker must have seen in the Scout magazines.
When prints had been made, Arthur Elliott took them along to his fellow photographer, and asked him whether he liked them. “Bill” Baker had the Scout knowledge, and was asked whether the pictures were a true reflection of Scout boyhood. The result was that Arthur Elliott gave Mr. Baker the negative of the three boys, and a print was sent to the “Scout Magazine” in London, where it was reproduced.
The story of how it came back to South Africa might seem to strain credulity, but it is true and vouched for by Mr. Baker, who is still connected with Scouting.
Evidently the picture reproduced in the “Scout Magazine” attracted the attention of a firm of metal workers, who, at the time, were making trophies for the Boy Scouts. They obtained the print and soon afterwards Joe Baker of the Second Claremont Group appeared in bronze on a Scout trophy.
On day Mr. “Bill” Baker and another Scout leader were talking to the later M. Haines, who was interested in youth work and started the Gordon’s Institute. “You’re interested in boys,” said Mr. Baker’s colleague. “Why don’t you do something for the Scouts?”
Mr. Haines promptly accepted the challenge. “I will,” he replied. “I will give you a trophy.”
So an order for a Scout trophy was sent to the London Scout Headquarters and passed on to the regular makers of these things. Thus it happened that Joe Baker, in bronze, came back to South Africa on the Gordon’s Shield.
There are other posed pictures and statuettes of a similar type, and I know that the Withinshaw Trophy, for instance, was that of a pose by a Cornish boy. But, although the order merely stated, “a Scout shield,” and the makers were given a free hand, the one dispatched turned out to be the one inspired by Arthur Elliott’s photo on the Kommetje Road.
The photograph taken in 1909 became a shield for competition in Cape Town in 1915, and when the trophy was first presented Joe Baker received a special invitation to attend and hear the story of his hike over again, as by that time he was over the age for competitive work as a Boy Scout.
Mr. Baker is still in our midst, as young in spirit as he looks on the Gordon’s Shield, which is being competed for again this weekend. 
Gordon Shield Winners
|2019||Hawequas||Simon Grantham||1st Claremont|
|2018||Hawequas||Conrad Thomas||1st Claremont|
|2017||Hawequas||Nimmy Abrahams||1st Bergvliet|
|2016||Hawequas||John Fraser||1st Monte Vista|
|2015||Hawequas||Charles Prince||2nd Fish Hoek|
|2014||Hawequas||Richard Storey||1st Monte Vista|
|2013||Hawequas||Nimmy Abrahams||1st Pinelands|
|2012||Hawequas||Ingrid Webster||2nd Somerset West|
|2011||Hawequas||Ubayd Bapoo||2nd Somerset West|
|2010||Chrysalis Academy Tokai||Mario Penso||2nd Fish Hoek|
|2009||Hawequas||Nimmy Abrahams||2nd Fish Hoek|
|2008||Hawequas||Ingrid Webster||2nd Fish Hoek|
|2007||Hawequas||2nd Fish Hoek|
|2006||Hawequas||Peter Meyer||2nd Fish Hoek|
|2005||Hawequas||Nimmy Abrahams||2nd Fish Hoek|
|2004||Hawequas||Jeremy Cheney||2nd Fish Hoek|
|2003||Hawequas||Andre Foot||2nd Fish Hoek|
|2002||Hawequas||Buzz Macey & Denzil Roberts||1st Durbanville|
|2001||Hawequas||Nigel Forshaw||2nd Bergvliet|
|2000||Hawequas||Rex Koning||2nd Bergvliet|
|1999||Hawequas||Denzil Roberts||1st Pinelands|
|1998||Hawequas||Errol Kotze||1st Pinelands|
|1997||Hawequas||David van Eck||1st Pinelands|
|1996||Hawequas||Buzz Macey||2nd Bergvliet|
|1995||Hawequas||Craig Mullett||2nd Bergvliet|
|1994||Errol Kotze||3rd Pinelands|
|1993||Hawequas||Albert Snyman||1st Durbanville|
|1992||Hawequas||Buzz Macey||1st Durbanville|
|1991||Errol Kotze||2nd Hout Bay|
|1990||Buzz Macey||1st Durbanville|
|1989||Errol Kotze||1st Durbanville|
|1988||Stellenbosch||Errol Kotze||1st Durbanville|
|1987||Gilcape, Eerste River||Jerry Wilding||1st Durbanville/2nd Somerset West|
|1986||Gilcape, Eerste River||Errol Kotze||1st Pinelands|
|1984||Gilcape, Eerste River||Richard Goldschmidt||1st Monte Vista|
|1983||Gilcape, Eerste River||Lionel Cohen||4th Rondebosch|
|1982||Gilcape, Eerste River||Brian Figaji||1st Somerset West|
|1981||Gilcape, Eerste River||1st Somerset West|
|1980||Gilcape, Eerste River||Lionel Cohen||2nd Somerset West|
|1979||Gilcape, Eerste River||Lionel Cohen||1st Pinelands|
|1978||Gilcape, Eerste River||Lionel Cohen||1st Pinelands|
|1977||Gilcape, Eerste River||Lionel Cohen||1st Somerset West|
|1976||Gilcape, Eerste River||Lionel Cohen||2nd Rondebosch/1st Pinelands|
|1975||Gilcape, Eerste River||Lionel Cohen||2nd Rondebosch|
|1974||Gilcape, Eerste River||Lionel Cohen||1st Durbanville|
|1973||Gilcape, Eerste River||E J 'Impie' Bryant||1st Pinelands|
|1972||Gilcape, Eerste River||E 'Fatty' Rutter||1st Claremont|
|1971||Gilcape, Eerste River||E 'Fatty' Rutter||1st Claremont/1st Parow|
|1970||Gilcape, Eerste River||E 'Fatty' Rutter||2nd Pinelands/1st Claremont|
|1969||Gilcape, Eerste River||E 'Fatty' Rutter||5th Observatory|
|1968||Gilcape, Eerste River||E 'Fatty' Rutter||1st Pinelands|
|1967||Gilcape, Eerste River||E 'Fatty' Rutter||1st Claremont|
|1966||Gilcape, Eerste River||E J 'Impie' Bryant||(No info available)|
|1965||Gilcape, Eerste River||E J 'Impie' Bryant||1st Claremont|
|1964||Gilcape, Eerste River||E J 'Impie' Bryant||1st Pinelands/1st Strand|
|1963||Gilcape, Eerste River||E J 'Impie' Bryant||2nd GASP|
|1962||Gilcape, Eerste River||E J 'Impie' Bryant||7th GASP|
|1961||Gilcape, Eerste River||E J 'Impie' Bryant||2nd Kenilworth|
|1960||Gilcape, Eerste River||E J 'Impie' Bryant||20th Cape Town|
|1959||Gilcape, Eerste River||2nd Rondebosch|
|1958||Gilcape, Eerste River||E 'Fatty' Rutter||10th GASP|
|1957||Gilcape, Eerste River||6th Rondebosch|
|1956||Gilcape, Eerste River||4th Rondebosch|
|1955||Gilcape, Eerste River||A Maspero||2nd GASP/7thGASP|
|1954||Gilcape, Eerste River||A Maspero||4thRondebosch/2nd Muizenberg|
|1953||Gilcape, Eerste River||A Maspero||7th GASP|
|1952||Gilcape, Eerste River||Carl "Serpent" Rayner||2nd GASP|
|1951||Maynardville, Wynberg||Carl "Serpent" Rayner||7th GASP|
|1950||Maynardville, Wynberg||H L 'Sandpiper' Stern||7th GASP|
|1949||Gilcape, Diep River||H L 'Sandpiper' Stern||4th Rondebosch/7th GASP|
|1948||Gilcape, Diep River||H L 'Sandpiper' Stern||2nd GASP|
|1947||The Glen, Camps Bay||H L 'Sandpiper' Stern||2nd GASP|
|1946||The Glen, Camps Bay||2nd Rondebosch|
|1945||Gilcape, Diep River||Frank 'Kudu' Quinn||2nd GASP|
|1944||Gilcape, Diep River||Carl "Serpent" Rayner||2nd Muizenberg|
|1942||Gilcape, Diep River||Frank 'Kudu' Quinn||2nd Muizenberg|
|1941||Gilcape, Diep River||Carl "Serpent" Rayner||2nd Muizenberg|
|1940||Gilcape, Diep River||J H Johnson||1st Mowbray|
|1930||Pinelands||7th Cape Town|
|1928||Pinelands||7th Cape Town|
|1926||1st Claremont grounds|
|1925||4th Rondebosch/1st GASP|
|1920||The Homestead, Oranjezicht||1st GASP|
|1919||7th Cape Town|
|1918||7th Cape Town|
|1916||Groote Schuur Estate||Capt. J. J. Walsh, District Signalling Officer||3rd Claremont|
|1915||Belmont Estate Rondebosch||Dr. Bennie Hewat, M.P.C., and Major St. Leger||2nd Cape Town YMCA|
- Argus, 3 May, 1947